World Bulletin / News Desk
A federal judge issued a 75-page ruling on Wednesday that declares that the US Justice Department does not have a legal obligation to explain the rationale behind killing Americans with targeted drone strikes, RT reported.
United States District Court Judge Colleen McMahon wrote in her finding this week that the Obama administration was largely in the right by rejecting Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requests filed by the American Civil Liberties Union and The New York Times for materials pertaining to the use of unmanned aerial vehicles to execute three US citizens abroad in late 2011.
Anwar al-Awlaki and Samir Khan, both US nationals, were killed on September 30 of that year using drone aircraft; days later, al-Awlaki’s teenage son, Abdulrahman al-Awlaki, was executed in the same manner.
Although the Obama administration has remained largely quiet about the killings in the year since, a handful of statements made from senior White House officials, including Pres. Barack Obama himself, have provided some but little insight into the Executive Branch’s insistence that the killings were all justified and constitutionally-sound. Attempts from the ACLU and the Times via FOIA requests to find out more have been unfruitful, though, which spawned a federal lawsuit that has only now been decided in court.
Siding with the defendants in what can easily be considered as cloaked in skepticism, Judge McMahon writes that the Obama White House has been correct in refusing the FOIA requests filed by the plaintiffs.
"There are indeed legitimate reasons, historical and legal, to question the legality of killings unilaterally authorized by the Executive that take place otherwise than on a 'hot' field of battle," McMahon writes in her ruling. Because her decision must only weigh whether or not the Obama administration has been right in rejecting the FOIA requests, though, her ruling cannot take into consideration what sort of questions — be it historical, legal, ethical or moral — are raised by the ongoing practice of using remote-controlled drones to kill insurgents and, in these instances, US citizens.
"The Alice-in-Wonderland nature of this pronouncement is not lost on me; but after careful consideration, I find myself stuck in a paradoxical situation in which I cannot solve a problem because of contradictory constraints and rules — a veritable Catch-22,” she writes. “I can find no way around the thicket of laws and precedents that effectively allow the Executive Branch of our Government to proclaim as perfectly lawful certain actions that seem on their face incompatible with our Constitution and laws, while keeping the reason for their conclusion a secret.”
Throughout her ruling, Judge McMahon cites speeches from both Pres. Obama and Attorney General Eric Holder in which the al-Awlaki killings are vaguely discussed, but appear to do little more than excuse the administration’s behavior with their own secretive explanations.
Obama called for an easing of inflamed Russia-Turkey tensions in a closed-door meeting with Russia's Vladimir Putin on the eve of a climate summit in Paris
Baku accuses Armenian forces of killing Azerbaijani soldier inlatest clash in diputed Nagorny Karabakh region
German Defense Ministry says call for broader coalition against ISIL does not involve Syrian regime forces
'What greater rejection for those who would tear down our world then marshaling our best efforts to save it,' says US president in Paris
Russian President Putin held closed-door talks with his US counterpart Obama on sidelines of UN climate conference in France
'When it comes to the Middle East peace process, the EU continues and will continue to work on this,' European Commission foreign affairs spokeswoman says
Key quotes from opening statements of world leaders at Paris climate summit
Istanbul-Frankfurt scheduled flight lands in Germany's Nürnberg Airport after mobile phone found in cabin
Putin will not meet with Erdogan at Paris climate conference, Kremlin says
Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi has told that rich nations of their duty to lead climate change fight
An attack blamed on eastern Ugandan rebels has killed 12 in DRC.
Teenager Mohammad Abu Khdeir was kidnapped and burnt to death in 2014. Relatives say the family plans to file a case against the government in the International Criminal Court.
'Those who claim to believe in God must also be men and women of peace,' Pope says
About 150 world leaders, including from the United States, China, India and Russia, converge in French capital
Power cuts in Ghana have been seen as biggest test for John Mahama government ahead of election in 2016