World Bulletin / News Desk
The top U.S. housing regulator rebuffed a plan by the Obama administration to cut mortgages held by struggling homeowners, a blow to the White House, which is keen to show voters it can help fix the housing market.
The regulator for government-run housing finance giants Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac said on Tuesday that using taxpayer-funded bank bailout money could encourage defaults and not make a big improvement in reducing foreclosures in a cost-effective way for taxpayers.
"The anticipated benefits do not outweigh the costs and risks," said the Federal Housing Finance Agency's head Edward DeMarco, who has come under intense pressure from the government to agreeto the plan.
The regulator's decision drew an immediate rebuke from the Obama administration and Democratic lawmakers. Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner disputed the agency's conclusions and urged DeMarco to reconsider his decision.
The housing market started deteriorating in 2006 and wiped out trillions of dollars in equity. A lthough t he market has shown signs of recovery, about 11 million homeowners owe more than their properties are worth and the Obama administration has struggled with various taxpayer-funded programs to keep people in their homes.
"I do not believe it is the best decision for the country," Geithner told DeMarco in a letter released to the media.
The use of targeted principal reduction would "provide much needed help to a significant number of troubled homeowners, help repair the nation's housing market and result in a net benefit to taxpayers," Gei thner sa id.
Despite several plans to tac kl e the country's housing problems, most of which is focuse d on giving homeowners the opportunity to refinance at lower interest rates, the ad ministration has yet to come up with a plan to stabilize the market.
Obama , a Democrat, is trying to convince voters ahead of the November presidential election that his policies have helped the economy recover from dire days of the financial crisis and ensuing recession. His Republican challenger, Mitt Romney, has said the foreclosure process should be allowed to run its course and hit the bottom.
GEITHNER, DEMARCO LOCK HORNS OVER ANALYSIS
Geithner pointed out that DeMarco's own data showed that the program would help nearly half a million homeowners and save taxpayers as much as $1 billion.
The housing regulator responded saying that figure only applied to a group of homeowners that had not made a mortgage payment in a year and would assume all those borrowers would win amortgage writedown -- a scenario deemed unlikely.
Rather, DeMarco's analysis showed that the projected net benefit to taxpayers would be $500 million in the best case scenario and its experience has shown that the likelihood of successfully modifying mortgages was small.
The administration has pressed DeMarco to allow Fannie and Freddie to do more principal writedowns. But DeMarco has maintained that this would needlessly drive up the costs of their taxpayer bailout.
Fannie and Freddie, which have received $190 billion in rescue funds to stay afloat, were seized by the government in 2008 amid threats of insolvency due to losses on subprime loans.
Although the regulator found that using the taxpayer bailout funds could result in about 74,000 to248,000 borrowers being eligible for the mortgage reductions, it said "nearly all of this benefit is simply a transfer from taxpayers" and would rack up the tab for the public.
Implementing the program "would actually increase taxpayer costs," said DeMarco.
After spending six months studying whether to use the taxpayer funds, DeMarco's agency concluded that the program would not only be costly and time-consuming to implement but could also send the wrong message to troubled borrowers who might choose to default to win a mortgage reduction.
The Obama administration wants to use money from the $700 billion Troubled Asset Relief Program topay Fannie and Freddie as much as 63 cents for every dollar of mortgage debt they forgive.
DECISION GOOD FOR LENDERS
Democratic lawmakers blasted the FHFA's decision.
"It is incomprehensible that Mr. DeMarco would reject the chance to save up to a billion dollars in taxpayer funds while helping nearly half a million homeowners stay in their homes," said Representative Elijah Cummings.
Senator Robert Menendez called DeMarco's decision "terrible" and said it underscores the regulator's intransigence when it comes to debt forgiveness for homeowners even as his own analysis shows the benefit to taxpayers.
The Washington Research Group viewed the decision as positive for banks, mortgage insurers and home builders as it removed the threat of a new wave of strategic defaults.
In a letter to lawmakers, DeMarco justified his actions and said borrowers could already obtain relief through programs already in place. The regulator also streamlined its refinancing program and removed certain loan requirements.
It plans to issue new standards in September for the representations and warranties that banks maketo Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac about their loans.
Exit would cost average monthly salary for each household, Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development says
Firms to see deterioration in credit metrics as low oil prices impact cash flows
OPEC exporters as well as other non-OPEC producers, including Russia, fail to agree on oil output freeze
Moody's has upgraded Argentina's credit rating after a US appeals court ruling this week cleared the way for Buenos Aires to proceed with the biggest debt issue by an emerging market country in 20 years.
Ahead of Doha meeting, OPEC says 'hurdles prevail as oversupply persists and inventories remain high'
Kuwaiti OPEC head says Russia and OPEC are likely to agree on oil output freeze
'The good news is that the recovery continues; we have growth; we are not in crisis,' Christine Lagarde says
The meeting is a 'follow-up' to last month's talks between Qatar, Russia, Saudi Arabia and Venezuela when they proposed an accord to freeze oil output at January levels
'They are not trimming output, only keeping it at the same levels...this is the same unchanged policy,' one expert says
Iran joining Venezuela, Saudi Arabia, Qatar and Russia in freezing oil output levels
According to the ratings agency Moody’s, Iran is fiscally and structurally well placed to come back into the global economic scene
PM Davutoglu meets the heads of the world's largest companies as he promotes Turkish economic interests at World Economic Forum
Fund cuts global growth forecasts for both 2016 and 2017 by 0.2 percentage points
'Runaway inequality has created a world where 62 people own as much wealth as the poorest half of the world’s population'