World Bulletin/News Desk
Facing unprecedented political opposition, three Florida Supreme Court justices are fighting back against Republicans and conservative activists seeking to change the balance in the state's highest court by getting voters to fire them.
Justices Fred Lewis, Barbara Pariente, and Peggy Quince face what is called a "merit retention" vote in November.
Normally that would be a routine affair with little political campaigning. This time, the three have been targeted by the Republican Party and conservative advocacy groups who accuse them of judicial activism.
Last month, Florida's Republican Party launched a public broadside against the three justices, saying they were "too extreme." Days later, Americans for Prosperity, a conservative group with strong ties to billionaire brothers Charles and David Koch, launched its own ad campaign critical of the justices.
Even before the campaign against them picked up in late September, the three had long been criticized by conservatives. They have amassed more than $1 million in campaign funds, according to the latest campaign finance reports.
The reports show that for the two weeks ending Sept. 28, the three raised more than $130,000 between them. The vast majority of donations to their cause has come from attorneys and law firms.
Backers of the justices have also formed their own political committee, Defend Justice from Politics.
On Friday the justices took direct aim at the campaign to oust them, telling an audience of mostly law students at Florida State University that politics should be kept out of the courts.
The retention vote is nothing short of a litmus test on the independence of the court and the viability of a democratic state, Lewis said, at times choking back his emotions.
"If the system is preserved, I think the people can trust it and say we are not going to let partisan politics alter who we are as Floridians," he said.
Quince said the three justices knew after the 2010 elections that they would likely be targeted. "We had some inkling that this was going to happen and that is why we started preparing," Quince said.
The three have been on the prevailing side of decisions that have rankled Republicans and conservatives for more than a decade. In 2000, they joined the majority to demand that ballots be recounted in Florida's presidential election debacle.
In 2010, the trio also thwarted a state Republican-led constitutional amendment to oppose President Barack Obama's health care reform law. A reworded version of the non-binding amendment is back on the ballot in November's election.
Under Florida law, justices must face a merit retention vote every six years to stay on the bench.
In September, a Florida Bar survey gave the three justices an average approval rating of more than 90 percent. During the last retention vote in 2006, all three garnered at least 67 percent of the vote.
Florida Supreme Court justices are limited by judicial canons in what they can say. But Lewis, Pariente and Quince have stepped up their defense against what their supporters describe as spurious charges of "judicial activism."
"The average Floridian wants a fair court," said Lewis, who was appointed by Governor Lawton Chiles, a Democrat, in 1998. "They want an impartial court and they do not want decisions made for political considerations," Lewis said in an interview posted on his website.
"They do not want a judge or a judicial system that is beholden to special interest," added Pariente - also appointed by Chiles - on her campaign website.
Quince was appointed in the final weeks of Chiles' term and was backed by his successor as governor, Republican Jeb Bush.
If a majority votes against the three justices, replacements will be appointed by the state's Republican governor, Rick Scott, a former healthcare executive and avowed enemy of Obama's healthcare reform.
"The grassroots opposition to these judges stems from a long list of cases in which these justices have injected their own political views into their rulings," Florida Republican Party Chairman Lenny Curry wrote in a recent opinion column.
Some accuse the Republican Party, and conservative activists themselves, of taking partisanship and politicking too far.
"Although the (Florida Republican Party) was within its constitutional right to express its position publicly, it was a mistake for it to do so as a partisan position," said Roberto Martinez, a Republican attorney and former U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of Florida.
"It is a mistake for any political party to inject itself as partisans," he added.
The Florida Democratic Party has not taken a stand in the case, but the party's chairman, Rod Smith, has been an outspoken critic of the recall push.
"The last thing you want is for a message to be sent to judges that if you don't rule with us, you'll pay a price for it," said Smith, a former state prosecutor.
"Independent judiciary has been what has separated us, literally, from the rest of the world."
458 candidates, including 97 women, find their way to provincial council seats; IEC Chairman blames delay in announcing results to technical problems
The United Nations General Assembly adopts resolution granting observer status to the Developing-Eight, or D-8.
The Palestinian youths pelted Israeli troops with stones and empty bottles, but the troops responded by firing teargas and birdshot, wounding ten Palestinians and making dozens of others experience temporary asphyxiation
More than 36 million citizens are set to vote and choose among 29 political parties in Sunday's early general election.
Qatar has renounced deporting Muslim Brothers leaders, Egyptian media reported.
Ismail Radwan said that the new round of indirect negotiations will start on Monday in Cairo as scheduled
A Kurdish intelligence officer in Zumar said peshmerga forces had advanced from five directions in the early morning after coalition air strikes on ISIL positions
Soldiers exchanged heavy fire with the militants, whose exact affiliation was unclear, and had surrounded them by midday, security sources said
60 % of French prisoners are Muslims “originally or culturally” according to French deputy Guillaume Larrive
Colorectal cancer is the leading cancer in males followed by leukemia and prostate cancer, according to the registry.
"Egypt is fighting an existential war," al-Sisi said, going on to say that his country will take "measures" along border with the Gaza Strip following the attack
Human Rights Watch calls for prosecution of military involved in killing 85 Muslims in southern Thailand
Kurdish media claimed the first units tomorrow to across Turkey's border, but news on when the peshmerga will start their passage is denied
Hamas said that two members had been detained in Bethlehem and two others in Hebron late Friday.
Jabbari had been sentenced to death in accordance "qisas" (eye for an eye) law after being found guilty of stabbing dead an older man with a kitchen knife seven years ago.
Red flags bearing the logo of Italy's largest union, the CGIL, waved over town squares as thousands of people rallied behind the group's call for job creation and job security