World Bulletin/News Desk
The U.S. State Department is debating the wisdom of designating the Nigerian group Boko Haram a "foreign terrorist organization" despite entreaties from lawmakers and the Justice Department to do so.
U.S. diplomats are giving serious consideration to the arguments of a group of academics who sent a letter to Secretary of State Hillary Clinton this week urging her department not to apply the "terrorist" label to the group.
The professors said Boko Haram's tactics have "turned most Nigerians against them," and their reputation among other militants might be enhanced by a "terrorist" designation.
U.S. action might also validate the position of more radical elements of Boko Haram, which is divided into factions, the professors said.
The academics also argued that any U.S. move to label Boko Haram as a terrorist group would "effectively endorse excessive use of force" against the group by Nigerian security forces "at a time when the rule of law in Nigeria is in the balance."
Abuses by Nigerian security forces already have "facilitated radical recruitment," the professors said.
A group of Republican senators led by Scott Brown of Massachusetts introduced legislation on Thursday that would require the State Department to determine whether Boko Haram should be formally labeled a "foreign terrorist" group.
The designation would subject it to economic sanctions, including the freezing of U.S. bank accounts, and would make it illegal for anyone in the United States to provide support to the group.
Brown said the group had allegedly been responsible for more than 700 deaths in the last 18 months.
Senator Saxby Chambliss, vice-chairman of the Senate Intelligence Committee, said the group had been improving the design of its homemade bombs, which constitute a "serious threat to international and U.S. interests."
In the House of Representatives, Republican Patrick Meehan, who chairs a subcommittee on homeland security, has introduced an amendment that would force the administration to add Boko Haram to the terrorism list or explain why it was not doing so.
A congressional source said State Department representatives are lobbying Congress to stop such legislation.
U.S. government sources confirmed that the academics' arguments are being taken seriously at the State Department, where they have featured in internal discussions about the "terrorist" designation.
A. Carl Levan, an American University scholar who helped organize the letter to the State Department, said human rights groups had called attention to alleged "excesses" by Nigerian security forces, and said future abuses might only be encouraged if the United States puts a "terrorist" label on Boko Haram.
He also said that the principal legal consequence of an FTO designation -- giving U.S. authorities the ability to freeze the group's assets and take legal action against people who support it -- would have little effect, since "when they need money they rob a bank."
Officially, the State Department will only say that it is considering all the options.
"Working with the Nigerian government to address the growing threat of violent extremism in Nigeria is a top priority for the administration," said a spokeswoman for the department's Africa bureau.
The official added: "On the question of designating Boko Haram as a Foreign Terrorist Organization (FTO)...the Department does not comment in advance on such decisions. I can assure you, however, that the Department is reviewing all options with regards to Boko Haram, including designation as an FTO."
In January, the top counter-terrorism official at the Justice Department weighed in with the State Department in favor of an early move to impose U.S. sanctions on the group.
Assistant Attorney General Lisa Monaco said in a letter to the State Department's counter-terrorism chief that Boko Haram met the criteria for a "foreign terrorist" listing because it either engages in terrorism which threatens the United States or has a capability or intent to do so.
Monaco said that although Boko Haram attacks until now have occurred only within Nigeria, the United States should not underestimate the threat the group poses to U.S. interests. Reuters reported earlier this month on her letter, which was not released to the public.
EU energy commissioner says the aim of the proposals 'is simple: to prevent and mitigate possible security of gas supply crises'
Lyutvi Mestan's new party to be called the Democrats for Responsibility, Freedom and Tolerance, abbreviated 'DOST' in Bulgarian
The cause of the accident near Bad Aibling, around 60 kilometres southeast of Munich, is not immediately clear
The country's bombing mission against ISIL in Iraq and Syria is set to end by February 22
A stable Libya is in the interests of the whole of the Maghreb and the whole of Europe,' European Parliament chief says
Human Rights Watch urges US president to call for ‘dismissal of politically motivated charges’ against former opposition leader when he meets Malaysian PM next week
Greece cannot protect Europe, new line of defense should be established at borders with Greece, says Hungarian PM
Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus president says he wants to see Cyprus adopt two-zone federal structure
Presidential council has asked the Tobruk-based parliament to grant it an extra week to form unity govt under UN deal
'As we have seen in the tumult across the Middle East and North Africa, when governments do not lift up their citizens, it's a recipe for instability and strife,' US president says
'The passengers were intended for another airline, Turkish Airlines,' Daallo Airlines CEO says
Premier David Cameron's office fears that 'thousands of people' could be crossing into UK if the country leaves EU
According to an army source, Iraq is deploying thousands of troops hoping to retake the key northern city
'The idea is to send a message to migrants that there is a double fence so give up crossing illegally,' a senior army official says
A group of seven suspects have planned to stage attacks in the Russian capital, Saint Petersburg and the Sverdlovsk region, Russian FSB security service claims